Monday, April 13, 2015

Accessible Netflix Petition

Photo of Daredevil character, in black suit with mask over most of face, in front of nighttime NYC skyline
Petitioning Netflix: Make Daredevil Available to The Blind Community ... Change.org.

I rarely post two items in a row on the same topic, but this “Daredevil” accessibility issue with Netflix is the Platonic Ideal of a disability advocacy issue:

- Netflix still won’t provide Audio Description for the blind for its new “Daredevil” series … or any of its other shows for that matter.

- “Daredevil” is a TV adaptation of a Marvel Comics superhero who is blind.

- A CNBC story says that it costs between $1,000 and $5,000 to provide Audio Description, the amount depending on length of a show. That seems like a lot of money for you and me, but for Netflix? Come on.

- Netflix’s non-response response, after almost 3 years of advocacy, suggests that there’s no real opposing view here. It’s just apathy and neglect. That is sadly typical of disability issues, where the most common enemy isn’t opposition, but indifference.

- The issue is important to blind people in a very direct way. It is important to all disabled people as a matter of principal and precedent. Yet, it is not so important or complex that it scares off people who don't like getting involved in advocacy with intense emotions, a steep learning curve, and a lot at stake.

Please sign the Change.org petition, Tweet it, and Facebook it.

----------

Saturday, April 11, 2015

Daredevil: Live Tweet, First Impressions, and an Epic Accessibility Fail

Poster for Daredevil TV show, with portrait of Matt Murdock, young man in suit wearing round sunglasses and adjusting his tie, smiling
Last nights Daredevil live tweet, under the #DaredevilDVP hashtag, was a blast. Alice Wong has assembled a Storify to archive the event.

Marvels Daredevil itself, the new Netflix series posted just yesterday, is pretty great, too. It’s dark without being gloomy, funny but not frivolous, and the action is exciting and violent without (yet) feeling dehumanizing … though parental discretion is most definitely advised. I have only seen the first episode, but the show is very promising.

Screen shot of Daredevil in action, at night, with police car nearby, man beaten on the ground at his feetAs disability depictions go, Matt Murdock / a.k.a. Daredevil, the blind superhero isnt bad, but not yet a revelation. The show indulges in a few blindness cliches, like face-touching and wishing to see again. But the show does interesting things with these themes and they feel more earned and specific than usual. My only concern is that if Murdock continues dropping clever one-liners about being blind, well into the series, the whole Get it? Im blind! schtick could become stale. My guess is that the blindness stuff will fade into the background while we dig into the story.

By all means, watch Daredevil. But while you watch, ponder the fact that while blindness is an integral part of the Daredevil story, Netflix so far has not provided an Audio Description track that would enable blind viewers to enjoy the show fully. Its bad corporate citizenship for Netflix to neglect Audio Description as it does for all shows, but its laughably terrible PR for them to leave it out of this show in particular, and to fail to respond meaningfully to people who have been asking about it since last summer.

Bold white logo AD, for Audio Description
Tom DiChristopher, CNBC - April 10, 2015


Get it together, Netflix. You've got another good show there. Don't ruin it by stonewalling on Audio Description. Just make it happen.

----------

Thursday, April 9, 2015

Throwback Thursday

Illustration of the time machine from the film "Time Machine".
A year ago in Disability thinking  Justice Department Agreement On Sheltered Workshops.

The arguments for and against Sheltered Workshops don’t change. Even the hopeful stories sound the same, from year to year, while the overall debate doesn’t seem to move forward.

----------

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Disability.TV Ep. 22 - Mini-Cast: Ratings Recap

Disability.TV logo on the left, microphone icon on the right




Disability.TV Star Ratings Google Doc ... See star ratings for every show reviewed on the Disability.TV Podcast.

#DaredevilDVP Live Tweet ... Hashtag discussion about the new Netflix show, DaredevilFriday, April 10, 8:00 PM Eastern

Hear More And Subscribe:


If you are so inclined, please leave an iTunes or Stitcher review. Positive reviews help more people discover the Disability.TV Podcast.

Comment:

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Blogging Break For Spring Cleaning

3 black silhouette figures doing housework, to illustrate "Housekeeping"
I am going on a blogging break this week, while I look into the possibility of moving the whole kit and caboodle over to a new Squarespace site. Does anyone have any feedback on Squarespace? How is it with accessibility?

Aside from hopefully finishing and posting the next Disability.TV Podcast episode later today, there probably wont be any blogging again until Sunday or Monday at the latest.

----------

Monday, April 6, 2015

Video Of The Day


TED Talks are meant to showcase ground-breaking, innovative, unorthodox people and ideas. This is pretty basic, entry-level disability stuff.

I dont meant that as an insult to Torrie Dunlap. She does a very good job of explaining accessibility, adaptation, inclusion, and the different models of thinking about disability. I especially want special needs parents to see this. It's a very kind but forceful pushback against the "special" everything impulse.

Still, it is frustrating that these simple, quite standard and established ideas about disability are apparently still new enough to mainstream ears to be the subject of a TED Talk. I guess its good, then, that even though the whole TED Talk phenomenon can get a little irritating, it has given a valuable outlet to disability leaders and role models like Maysoon Zayid, the late Stella Young, and others.

I just wonder how many more decades it will be before ideas like this provoke nods and yawns instead of applause.

----------

Saturday, April 4, 2015

#DaredevilDVP

Disability Visibility Project - April 4, 2015

Netflix’s live-action Daredevil” TV show may turn out be the biggest disability on TV story of the year. Based on the Marvel Comics series about a blind superhero, the whole first season of “Daredevil will be posted at once on Friday, April 10. Alice Wong of the Disability Visibility Project will host a live Tweeting event starting 8 PM Eastern, under the #DaredevilDVP hashtag. We will be posting Tweets while we watch the first episode. Anyone interested is invited to follow and participate.

I am not a comic book fan. I never have been. Nor have I clicked into any of the superhero movies and TV shows of the last 30 or so years. Going in, my interest is mainly curiosity about how Daredevils blindness is portrayed.

There is a familiar stereotype baked into the premise  that being blind intensifies the other senses. Its a popular idea that is only partially, if at all true in real life. I'll be interested to see whether making these heightened senses "superpowers" will make them more of a blindness stereotype or less. Also, as far as I know, the actor, Charlie Cox, isnt blind. That is disappointing, and puts me on alert for possible inaccuracies and shortcuts in the portrayal of a blind man. On the plus side, it looks like Daredevil might be trained and advised by another blind man. That kind of peer mentoring is one of my favorite things to see in disability on TV.



I will try to keep an open mind. If its a good show overall, then I’m prepared to be pleased if blindness is just another factor, the way paralysis is a factor, but not always a crucial one for “Ironside, a less fantastical disabled TV crime fighter.

----------

Facebook

Friday, April 3, 2015

Disability Blogger Link-Up

The word Blog surrounded by word cloud
Use the whatsizdigas below to post a blog post or article on something related to disability  something you want to share.

To make the articles easier to browse, in the “Your name” blank, type the title of the article. In the "Your URL" blank, paste the whole website address of the thing you are posting.

Then click the "Enter" button. That's it!

Note: If your post doesn't appear immediately, try "refreshing" the page a few times. Sometimes it takes a little while to show up. Also, feel free to post more than one item. Finally, you might want to add a comment at the bottom of this post, to identify yourself or add an explanation or comment about the items you are posting.

Have fun posting and reading! This Link-Up will close at Midnight Eastern on Sunday. Look for the next Link-Up Friday, April 17, 2015.

Thursday, April 2, 2015

Making Accessible Campaign Propaganda (ahem) Materials

BBC News - March 26, 2015

I am not aware of anyone in the United States making a high-profile, publicized attempt to produce political campaign materials specifically for voters with intellectual disabilities. It sounds like a worthwhile thing to do, and a pretty interesting task.

For one thing, there are so many types and shades of intellectual disability ... which I believe is what the BBC means when they say, "learning disability".

And how, exactly, does one "translate" a party platform so that intellectually disabled people can understand it? What does "simplifying" mean? Do you take out all the metaphors and colloquial phrases? Do you use shorter words and fewer compound sentences? How does "large print" help an intellectually disabled person with (most likely) normal eyesight?

Or, is it about more than grammar and font size? Are there social studies texbooks designed to teach adults with intellectual disabilities what "liberal", "conservative", and "libertarian" mean? Do you try to alert intellectually disabled voters to opaque, misleading slogans that all sound good, even when they contradict each other?

I would really like to learn more about this.

----------

Facebook

Throwback Thursday

Illustration of the time machine from the film "Time Machine".A year ago in Disability thinking  Day Off.

A year ago today the weather was nice enough to tear me away from blogging. Today it might snow.

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

Disabled TV Character Face-Off: Sixth Round

In the fifth round, Walter Flynn White, Jr. beat Max Braverman.
Chart showing Max Braverman at a little over 30%, and Walter "Flynn" White with a little under 70%
Here is the updated bracket:
Round six pits John Bates, of Downton Abbey, against Bran Stark from Game Of Thrones. Which character do you like best?

Photo of middle aged white man in a suit.
John Bates
Disability: Limp from a leg wound.
Role on the show: Secondary character in ensemble cast.

Photo of a white boy outdoors wearing a wolf-skin cloak
Bran Stark
Disability: Paraplegia.
Role on the show: Secondary character in ensemble cast.
Create your free online surveys with SurveyMonkey , the world's leading questionnaire tool.

----------

Facebook